I started with a recruiter call, and the whole process moved quickly from there. Next I went through a series of interviews with different people from the team—often multiple managers on the call—where the tone was pretty relaxed and straightforward. Even when there were a few more voices involved, the questions still felt like normal conversation: why I wanted the role, how my background lined up, and general fit for sales.
The later rounds stayed focused on practical discussion rather than anything overly hostile. In my last step, the team included a mock pitch format for a moment, but they ended up not using it and just did a regular interview instead. That last conversation still followed the same theme of assessing how I would communicate and handle the role day-to-day, and I felt like I could come across clearly.
> 1 year
Average Positive Chicago, IL
I went through a more transparent loop than I expected for sales, starting with a recruiter conversation and then moving into manager discussions fairly quickly. The interviews felt structured around reviewing my experience and talking through the role, with managers who were open and direct about what they were looking for.
At some point in the later rounds, I was walked through background and behavioral questions, but it never felt overly tense or performative. Even when the process moved through multiple conversations, it mostly stayed conversational—like they were trying to understand how I thought rather than just pushing gotcha-style questions.
> 1 year
Average Neutral Colombia
I went into the process expecting it to be fairly standard, and it did start that way with a recruiter screen. After that, I met the hiring manager an…
> 1 year
Easy Positive Chicago, IL
I had a very compact interview path that leaned heavily on getting right to sales communication. After a recruiter step, I sat for a quick set of conv…
> 1 year
Average Negative San Francisco, CA
My process kicked off normally with recruiter contact, and then it moved into multiple rounds that were more “real sales practice” than just fit quest…
Unlock every Account Executive interview experience
Interviewed here recently? Add yours to help the next candidate. You'll appear as Anonymous.
What to expect
Distilled from the reports
Recruiter and Initial Screening
The interview process typically begins with a recruiter call focused on fit and interest in the sales role, often described as friendly and straightforward. Candidates should be prepared to discuss their background and motivations without feeling pressured.
Recruiter callFit assessmentSales motivation
Manager Interviews
Subsequent interviews with sales managers are generally conversational and focused on the candidate's experience and sales instincts, with an emphasis on practical discussions rather than technical grilling. Candidates should expect a mix of behavioral questions and discussions about day-to-day responsibilities.
Some candidates encounter role-play scenarios where they pitch Grubhub to potential clients or handle sales objections, testing their communication skills and sales approach. Being prepared for these simulations is crucial as they reflect real-world sales situations.
Role-playSales scenariosCommunication skills
Presentation Component
Later stages may include a presentation where candidates showcase their approach to the business or a specific sales strategy, which can be a significant part of the evaluation process. Candidates should practice presenting their ideas clearly and confidently.
PresentationSales strategyEvaluation
Process Consistency and Communication
Candidates often note the process's overall organization and the respectful tone maintained throughout, although some experienced delays or lack of follow-up after interviews. It's advisable to seek clarity on next steps and maintain communication with recruiters.
Process organizationCommunicationFollow-up
Outcome and Reflection
While many candidates felt the process was fair and well-structured, some expressed disappointment over not receiving offers or feedback after interviews. Reflecting on the experience and seeking feedback can help candidates prepare better for future opportunities.